Dunk imprisoned
Dunk in a prison cell.
Dunk in a prison cell.

Dunk waits for hours in a prison cell inside Ashford castle, after attacking Aerion Targaryen to defend Tanselle. Eventually he is visited by Egg - now dressed in royal finery and flanked by guards. Egg commands them to set down a tray of food for Dunk and leave them. Dunk eats hungrily, and Egg nervously says his uncle told him to beg Dunk's forgiveness for deceiving him. Dunk points out his uncle is in fact Crown Prince Baelor, heir to the Iron Throne. Egg says he never meant to lie, to which Dunk shoots back that he lied about everything - including his name, as he never heard of a "Prince Egg." The boy explains that it's short for "Aegon," which is instantly recognizable as a Targaryen name. Dunk chides him by asking how many "Aegons" have been king by now, and he admits there have been four "Aegons" already who sat the Iron Throne.

Prince Aegon Targaryen visits Dunk in his cell.
Prince Aegon Targaryen visits Dunk in his cell.

Aegon "Egg" Targaryen slumps down to sit against a wall while Dunk asks, as much to the boy as to himself, if it was all just a cruel joke, a royal prince having some fun making a fool of a stupid lowly hedge knight. Egg explains that he was supposed to squire for his older brother Daeron, who he bluntly describes as "a shit knight and a drunk." Daeron didn't even want to enter the tourney lists, but only went to Ashford because their father Maekar pressured him. Daeron meant to hide at the inn where Dunk first met him, about a day's ride to the south, until the tourney was over. Daeron has more dirty-blond hair, but Egg's hair is classic Targaryen silver-white, so Daeron shaved his brother's head to avoid notice.

Dunk counters by asking if it was Daeron and not him who lied and told Dunk he was a stable boy. Tears start welling up in Egg's eyes and he stammers that he didn't think he was doing anything wrong, but Dunk interjects that of course he knew it was wrong otherwise he wouldn't have lied. Egg pleads that he just wanted so much to be a squire and was so disappointed when he couldn't go to the tourney. Dunk accuses that Egg was so set on finding a replacement for Daeron that he'd have squired for a donkey if it would have taken him to the tourney, and Dunk meant nothing to him. Egg can only say he's truly sorry, and that his uncle Baelor wants to see Dunk after he's done eating. Dunk gets up to leave immediately, saying that he's already kicked one prince in the mouth so he shouldn't keep a second one waiting.


Advertisement
Baelor's counsel
Aegon, his uncle Baelor, and Dunk discuss what to do.
Aegon, his uncle Baelor, and Dunk discuss what to do.

A guard brings Dunk and Egg to Baelor, who is studying old law books in Lord Ashford's library. Despite being upset about the deception, Dunk's first words are to tell Baelor that Egg is a good boy and a good squire, who meant no harm. Baelor says Aegon should have come to him when he saw what Aerion was doing to the puppeteers. Egg tries to interject that there simply wasn't time, but Baelor continues that instead the boy ran to Ser Duncan and dragged him into this situation. Egg looks at the floor and solemnly says he wishes Dunk had killed Aerion. Baelor insists that Aerion is his brother, and the septons say all must love their brothers, then bids the boy to leave.

Baelor starts by asking Dunk how skilled he is at arms, and Dunk admits he had some basic training from Ser Arlan - but doesn't have years of training from the best warriors in the realm like a prince would have. Baelor stands and paces, and informs Dunk that Egg's father Maekar returned to the castle a few hours ago having found his son Daeron drunk at the inn where Dunk found Egg. Daeron told Maekar that a "huge robber knight" made off with Aegon. Baelor knows that he was lying, and Dunk insists he left the inn alone and Daeron obviously remained at the inn instead of trying to pursue him.

Baelor advises Dunk that he has the right to a trial by combat.
Baelor advises Dunk that he has the right to a trial by combat.

Dunk asks what happened to the girl, and Baelor says Aerion is twisting the tale to accuse her of high treason and inciting revolt against the crown. Dunk is astonished, as it was just a harmless puppet show. Baelor says the dragon is the symbol of the royal family so this was unwise even in peacetime: Aerion calls it a veiled attack on House Targaryen. Dunk asks if Baelor even believes that, but he changes the subject to say what is beyond dispute is he struck a prince of royal blood - and it is never wise to strike a king's grandson.

Dunk angrily declares that Aerion snapped the girl's finger in half, and asks if Baelor would not have done the same in his place. Baelor admits he might have - but he is a prince and Aerion's uncle, not a hedge knight. Dunk pointedly asks him if all knights don't take the same oath to protect the innocent, to which Baelor looks away in silence.

After a moment, Baelor says that Aerion has demanded Dunk's head. He won't allow it, but even though he can ignore Daeron's accusation that he kidnapped Egg, he cannot deny Aerion's right to trial for Dunk striking him. The punishment the last time a commoner struck a royal was to have the offending limb cut off: Dunk not only punched Aerion but kicked him so he'd lose his hand and foot as well. Baelor then sympathetically says that Dunk has another option, though he cannot say if it is better or worse: rather than be maimed, as a knight Dunk can demand the right of trial by combat - though against a well-trained prince he would be risking death.


Advertisement
A trial of seven champions
The lords gather to hear Dunk's plea.
The lords gather to hear Dunk's plea.

Dunk is then brought before a hastily convened trial board in the castle study, consisting of Baelor, Maekar, Lord Ashford, and Leo Tyrell. Aerion is also present, scornfully cracking nuts on the table with the hilt of his dagger. Dunk nervously repeats that he chooses a trial by combat - only for Aerion to say he refuses. Confused, Maekar tells his son he can't refuse Dunk's right to the challenge. Aerion smugly responds that he instead invokes a "trial of seven."

Aerion demands a trial of seven.
Aerion demands a trial of seven.

Baelor explains that a trial of seven is an ancient variation of trial by combat, seldom invoked: the Andals believed that if the Seven were honored by seven champions fighting instead of only one, they were more likely to intervene and lend victory to the just claimant. Maekar is displeased with his son, asking if he's such a coward he has to hide behind some obscure custom rather than face this lowly hedge knight in single combat. Aerion claims he isn't, but he'd like to make a show of Targaryen strength and power to the lords assembled at the tourney; Dunk ostensibly also insulted Daeron as well, so Aerion feels he deserves a bigger punishment. Confused, Dunk asks if they seriously expect him to fight against seven men alone: chiding him as foolish, Aerion explains that the trial is two teams of seven against seven. Dunk objects that he is a lone wandering knight and doesn't know anyone at the tourney, but Aerion snidely says that if Dunk's cause is just, surely six other good men will volunteer to fight for him. Aerion also says that if Dunk cannot find six other champions by dawn, that means his cause is unjust, and Dunk forfeits the trial. Annoyed, Maekar drags Aerion out of the room while Baelor gives Dunk leave to go search for his champions.

Dunk consults the Fossoways.
Dunk consults the Fossoways.

Dunk returns to his camp in the hedges, and apologizes to his horses that he's really mucked things up now. Raymun Fossoway then comes looking for him and takes Dunk back to the Fossoway tent. Raymun's cousin Ser Steffon Fossoway says that he resents the Targaryens as foreign tyrants and he will take Dunk's side to oppose them. He also admits he isn't concerned about Dunk's cause being just, but winning fame and glory fighting against Targaryens in a rare trial of seven. Steffon then leaves saying he will look for five other knights. Raymun tells Dunk it may be wiser just to flee while he still can. Dunk points out that if he runs and is later caught he will be killed, but Raymun says if he stays and forfeits, he'll definitely die. With self-deprecation, Dunk wonders if this is the gods' punishment for him not knowing his lowly place in the world.


Advertisement
Daeron's dreams
Egg sneaks into the Fossoway tent to join Dunk as his squire.
Egg sneaks into the Fossoway tent to join Dunk as his squire.

Egg then enters the tent wearing a hooded cloak: he says he is Dunk's squire, and he will need someone to arm him in the trial. Dunk asks if his father knows he left the castle, but another hooded figure then enters the tent and says he hopes not: he pulls back his hood to reveal himself as Egg's eldest brother, Daeron the Drunken. Dunk immediately recognizes him as the drunk nobleman he encountered at the inn where he met Egg, seizing Daeron and slamming into a table for lying that he kidnapped Dunk. Daeron says he had to tell his father something when he was caught, and at Egg's pleading Dunk relents. Egg explains that his father has joined the seven accusers to defend his sons' honor, and is making Daeron join as well, though Daeron says he'll help Dunk by immediately collapsing from the first blow he takes.

Egg's eldest brother, Daeron the Drunken.
Egg's eldest brother, Daeron the Drunken.

Daeron also says that the three highly skilled Kingsguard knights already present in Ashford will also join. He doesn't know who their seventh champion will be, but Aerion has more chance of finding one than Dunk has of finding another five. Egg says he begged Maekar not to fight for Aerion but he refused, despite his contempt for Aerion's choice. Dunk worries that Egg will be upset that he shall be facing his family, but Egg explains that Maekar will be well protected by the Kingsguard, and Daeron will fall down. As for Aerion, Egg does not explicitly wish him dead, but says that when he was little, Aerion used to come into his bedchamber at night at slip a dagger between his legs, threatening to castrate him so he'd have another sister to marry; he also threw Egg's pet cat down a well, though he denies it. Daeron agrees that Aerion can be quite the monster. Egg says Aerion is insane, believing himself to be a dragon in human form; Daeron bitterly says it is a pity Aerion wasn't born a Fossoway, then he'd think himself an apple. Before going back to the castle, Daeron asks for a private word with Dunk outside.

Daeron reveals to Dunk that his dreams come true.
Daeron reveals to Dunk that his dreams come true.

As they stare at a campfire, Daeron tells Dunk that he dreamed of him. Dunk points out he told him that before when he first saw him at the inn, but he was too drunk to remember. Daeron explains that his dreams are not like Dunk's: his dreams come true. Daeron admits it is an impressive talent for an unimpressive man, but nonetheless he saw Dunk in a dream before he first met him. He saw Dunk, a fire, and a dead dragon: a massive dragon whose wings were as wide as this entire meadow. The dragon had fallen on top of Dunk, but Dunk was still alive and the dragon was dead. Believing Daeron's words, Dunk asks if he killed the dragon in the dream but Daeron says he doesn't know. Daeron looks back at the fire and remarks that the Targaryens were dragon masters once, though it is hard to believe now: the dragons are all dead yet the Targaryens remain. Daeron laments that he may have killed Dunk through his lie, and he is sorry. He turns to slink back into the castle, saying he knows he's already doomed to some kind of hell - probably one without wine.


Advertisement
A new shield
Dunk finds the Dornish tent abandoned, as the puppeteers fled to safety.
Dunk finds the Dornish tent abandoned, as the puppeteers fled to safety.

After Daeron departs, Dunk heads to the Dornish puppeteers' abandoned tent. Their broken puppets are left where Aerion's men smashed them. As he thinks of Tanselle the blacksmith Steely Pate calls Dunk to his wagon, saying that if he came for his shield she left it with him. Once inside he asks what happened to her and Pate says she and the other puppeteers are gone, already on their way to Dorne. Dunk is happy at this, as it means they left before Aerion could order them captured and Tanselle is safe.

Steely Pate brings out Dunk's newly repainted shield. It is exactly the design he asked for and beautifully rendered: a green elm tree on a sunset orange background, with a shooting star flying over it. Steely Pate took an extra step and replaced the metal rim, which was rusted cheap steel, with a new one twice as thick and bands on the back to make it heavier and stronger. Beginning to cry, Dunk looks at the design and notes that the star is falling and sunset heralds night: both are symbols of death, and he has brought death and ruin to all around him. Pate puts a hand on his shoulder and points out that the elm is green, alive with summer leaves.

Steely Pate asks Dunk if he remembers the old shield rhyme, that starts "Oak and iron guard me well..." and Dunk finishes "...or else I'm dead and doomed to hell." Dunk asks him how much he wants for the new rim and repairs, but with a stroke of his beard Steely Pate says "From you? A copper."

A knight who remembered his vows
Lyonel Baratheon and Robyn Rhysling take Duncan's side.
Lyonel Baratheon and Robyn Rhysling take Duncan's side.

At dawn, Dunk walks out to the mist-shrouded jousting tilts where the trial of seven is to be held. He sees that several other knights have come to take his side: Humfrey Hardyng, Humfrey Beesbury, Robyn Rhysling, and Lyonel Baratheon. Dunk says he is in their debt. Hardyng says the debt is Aerion's - he is there to pay him back for killing his horse and breaking his leg, and while he cannot walk he can still ride. The fanatically religious Ser Robyn says he would die the king's faithful servant, but when the crown goes against the gods he goes against the crown.

Dunk tells Lyonel Baratheon he is thankful for him and for Ser Steffon for bringing him, which confuses Lyonel as they were all brought there by Dunk's squire Egg. Lyonel says he joined because there hasn't been a trial of seven for a hundred years, and he couldn't pass up an opportunity to try himself against the Targaryen Kingsguard.

After putting on his full set of new armor from Steely Pate, Dunk and his supporters walk out into the arena and see Aerion and his champions enter the opposite side. Dunk is confused to see there are only six of them and asks if Aerion couldn't find a seventh man. Ser Steffon Fossoway then walks up in full armor and bluntly asks his cousin and squire Raymun for his helmet. Steffon flippantly says he is Aerion's seventh champion, fighting against Dunk. Aghast, Raymun says Steffon promised to support Duncan. Steffon casually explains that Aerion promised him a lordship for his support, and men have been known to sell their honor for far less. Steffon still expects Raymun to fetch him his horse, but he shoves his cousin's helmet back at him and says to get it himself.

As Steffon rides away to the other side, Raymun turns to Dunk and begs him to knight him so he can take his cousin's place. He may only be a moderately trained squire but unlike Steffon he can give his honor, as without him Dunk's side only has five men. Raymun drops to his knees in front of Dunk, who puts his hand on his hilt, but then hesitates to draw it out and says he can't. Seeing Dunk hesitate, Lyonel tells him to go on to the judges while he gives Raymun his knighthood. Just then horns announce that Lord Ashford and the rest have reached the royal viewing box. As Dunk rides away, Lyonel taps his sword on Raymun's shoulders, charging him in the name of the Warrior to be brave, in the name of the Father charging him to be just, in the name of the Mother to protect the young and innocent. Dunk doesn't hear the rest as he approaches Lord Ashford.

Aerion taunts Dunk that if he cannot find a seventh champion he forfeits.
Aerion taunts Dunk that if he cannot find a seventh champion he forfeits.

The nobles' viewing stands from the tourney are now filled again, and hundreds of commoners are gathered around the other side. When he approaches Aerion taunts that Dunk only has five champions, though Dunk corrects that he has six because Raymun is being knighted as they speak. Dunk asks to fight six against seven. Aerion smirks that it is not permitted, and Lord Ashford agrees the rule is if he cannot find a seventh champion he forfeits and is found guilty. Dunk begs to give him a moment to address the large gathered audience and Lord Ashford grants it.

After a tense silence finding his words, Dunk rides back and forth addressing the lords and knights in the stands. He says he knows they don't remember Ser Arlan of Pennytree or him Arlan's squire, but they served many of them honorably over the years. Ser Arlan was a good man and he taught Dunk how to be a knight: not just with sword and lance, but with honor. His voice almost breaking, Dunk shouts that a knight defends the innocent, and that's all he did. Dunk says he might not have been Arlan's blood, but he followed his example - as the lords' sons will follow theirs. Dunk finishes, asking who will stand and fight with him. Otho Bracken rises for a moment as if to join, only to then pass gas to mock Dunk's plea. The highborn viewing stands erupt in laughter, while the crowds of commoners remain deathly silent. After their laughter subsides, Dunk angrily shouts, asking if courage has deserted the noble houses of Westeros. He refuses to believe it. Dunk finally shouts:

"ARE THERE NO TRUE KNIGHTS AMONG YOU?!"

He is met with only silence across the entire field. A moment passes. Suddenly all turn when they hear the main tourney gates being opened, and a rider in the armor of Prince Valarr Targaryen comes out of the mist. The rider removes his helm, revealing himself to be none other than Crown Prince Baelor: he declares that he will take Ser Duncan's side.

"This man protected the innocent, as every true knight must
"This man protected the innocent, as every true knight must."

The crowds of commoners erupt into cheers, while the shamed lords in the viewing stands awkwardly rise to their feet in respect. Maekar rides up to his brother and asks if he has abandoned his senses: this man attacked his son Aerion. Baelor responds that this man protected the innocent, as every true knight must.

Baelor says the gods will now decide whether he was right or wrong.

Seven

Baelor's defense of Dunk reveals a heir who measures a man's worth by his deeds, not his blood, forcing the crown itself to choose between honor and dynasty.

Baelor's Admission of Shared Impulse

Silence on the Knightly Oath

Baelor Steers Dunk Toward Trial

Gods as Arbiter of Justice

Aerion's Trial as Power Display

Dunk's Honor Versus Formal Training

Baelor Targaryen's support for Dunk is not honor overcoming politics but a calculated displacement of his own unresolvable conflict: he has privately concluded that legitimacy derives from conduct rather than birth, but he will not say so and survive, so he engineers a legal mechanism that might say it for him. His silence when asked whether all knights share the same oath is not ambiguity but suppressed conviction. The trial of seven is the only structure in which Baelor can win his argument against Aerion without having to openly make it.

Baelor Chose Honor Over Blood

Dunk's hesitation to knight Raymun reveals he never actually received the accolade himself, masking a fundamental fraud in his identity.

Only a Robin as Witness

No Knighting Ceremony in Flashbacks

Dunk's Hesitation Before Knighting Raymun

Dunk Says 'I Shouldn't'

Parallel With Egg's Deception

Trial by Combat Right Depends on Knighthood

When Dunk says 'I shouldn't' before knighting Raymun, the show covertly discloses that Ser Arlan never formally knighted him, leaving a broken chain of conferral at the foundation of every legal right the episode depends on. This structural defect is the hidden engine of the cell scene: Dunk's anger at Egg does not dissolve through contrition but collapses when he recognizes that Egg's lie is identical in kind to his own fabricated knighthood, and prosecution of one requires prosecution of the other. From that moment, their bond is not trust restored but mutual exposure held in permanent silence.

Dunk Cannot Knight Because He Was Never Knighted

Dunk's Hesitation Discloses a Broken Chain: Two Fabricated Legitimacies, One Shared Silence

Aerion's belief he is a dragon removes him from reality itself, making him immune to law, family, and reason as checks on his violence.

Egg Names the Dragon Delusion

Puppet Show Triggers Extreme Violence

Treason Charge for Symbolic Content

Egg and Daeron Both Warn of Danger

Trial of Seven as Draconic Theater

Aerion's dragon delusion is confirmed, but what the show has not yet made explicit is its structural consequence: Aerion has exited the shared framework of reality that law, family, and reason operate within, which means every institution trying to check his violence is reasoning in a language he no longer speaks. His cruelty is not cruelty to him. It is proportionate justice, and that is what makes him untreatable.

Aerion Thinks He Is Literally a Dragon

Dunk's refusal to perform virtue exposes the hollow center of every power structure in Westeros, making genuine goodness the only currency the system cannot neutralize.

Baelor's Silence After Oath Challenge

Egg's Tearful Cell Confession

Dunk Defends Egg to Baelor Immediately

Rat Kindness in the Cell

Dunk and Egg Both Talk to Horses

Knightly Oath as Disruptive Language

The show is running the same argument through two registers at once: behaviorally, Dunk's unconditional goodness forces every character whose identity depends on the knightly-oath gap remaining unexamined into either honesty or a more naked form of dishonesty; symbolically, the elm on his shield names what that quality is. Pate's correction, 'The elm's alive, man,' is not comfort but a gloss on the behavioral mechanism the show is building in every scene with Baelor and the lords. Together, these registers constitute a structural bet the narrative is placing on itself: that moral sincerity is the one currency the court world cannot counterfeit, neutralize, or absorb.

Dunk's Virtue Breaks the Westeros Formula

Dunk's Moral Sincerity Is the One Thing the Westeros Architecture Was Never Built to Stop

Daeron's vision of Dunk beneath a fallen dragon predicts he will kill Aerion Targaryen, who literally believes himself to be a dragon.

Daeron's Self-Confirmed Prophetic Dreams

The Dead Dragon Vision Content

Aerion's Dragon Self-Belief

No Living Dragons in Westeros

Trial of Seven as Dream's Fire

Daeron's Drinking as Suppression

Daeron Abandons the Tourney

Daeron has foreseen Aerion's death at Dunk's hands, and his drinking and absence from Ashford are not weakness but the behavior of a man who already knows how the trial of seven ends. Since no dragon of the dream's scale exists in Westeros, the vast dead beast in Daeron's vision must signify Aerion, who explicitly understands himself to be a dragon in human form. The sharpest implication is not that Dunk wins, but that Daeron has been carrying the knowledge of his brother's death alone, and warned the killer without warning the condemned.

Daeron Dreams of Dunk Killing a Dragon

A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms

The Proverb Was the Hinge: Baelor's Death as Murder and Prophecy Simultaneously

Baelor Built a Closed Honor System With One Unguarded Entrance, and Dunk's Survival Was Its Contemptuous Remainder

Aerion Invokes Obscure Seven-Champion Rule

Forfeiture Framed as Proof of Injustice

Steffon's Grievance, Not Loyalty, Motivates Him

Dunk Acknowledges His Social Isolation

Dawn Deadline Designed to Maximize Pressure